Motions - Education, Employment and Workplace Relations Legislation Committee - Explanation needed
Senate, 2019-04-03. affirmative: ayes 34, noes 29.
Question
The majority voted in favour of a motion ↗︎ introduced by Tasmanian Senator Anne Urquhart ↗︎ (Labor), which means it succeeded. Motions like these don't make any legal changes on their own but are politically influential since they represent the will of the Senate.
Motion text
That the Senate—
(a) notes that: > >> (i) on 24 October 2017, an unauthorised leak to the media occurred concerning an upcoming raid by the Australian Federal Police and Registered Organisations Commission on the offices of the Australian Workers Union, >> >> (ii) the then Minister for Employment, Senator Cash, appeared before the Education and Employment Legislation Committee at the 2017-18 supplementary Budget estimates hearing on 25 October 2017, and misled the Senate five times regarding her office's involvement in the leak, and has since refused to correct the record, >> >> (iii) Senator Cash has since relied on this evidence, including by providing it in a letter to the Australian Federal Police, >> >> (iv) since giving evidence: >> >>> (A) former personal staff of Senator Cash have made admissions in court, under oath, about their role in leaking confidential information concerning the raid, >>> >>> (B) the Australian Federal Police gave evidence at the 2018-19 additional estimates that Senator Cash sent them a letter in relation to their investigation into the leak which they would not classify as a witness statement, that she refused to provide a witness statement despite at least two requests to do so, and that there was a prima facie case to support a conviction for a criminal offence in relation to the leak, beyond reasonable doubt, and >>> >>> *(C) the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions gave evidence at the 2018-19 additional estimates that there was a prima facie case to support a conviction for a criminal offence, it w
How each member voted
How each party voted
Party labels are those recorded for this division, rather than current affiliations.
- Liberal: no 19
- Labor: aye 19
- United Australia Party: no 1
- Nationals: no 2
- Derryn Hinch's Justice Party: aye 1
- Liberal Democratic Party: no 1
- Independent: no 2, aye 2
- LNP: no 2
- Greens: aye 9
- Country Liberal Party: no 1
- One Nation: aye 1
- PRES: no 1, aye 1
- Centre Alliance: aye 1
Noes
- Amanda Stoker (Liberal) — no
- Anne Ruston (Liberal) — no
- Arthur Sinodinos (Liberal) — no
- Brian Burston (United Australia Party) — no
- Bridget McKenzie (Nationals) — no
- Concetta Fierravanti-Wells (Liberal) — no
- David Fawcett (Liberal) — no
- Dean Smith (Liberal) — no
- Duncan Spender (Liberal Democratic Party) — no
- Eric Abetz (Liberal) — no
- Fraser Anning (Independent) — no
- Ian Macdonald (Liberal) — no
- James McGrath (LNP) — no
- James Paterson (Liberal) — no
- Jane Hume (Liberal) — no
- Jim Molan (Liberal) — no
- John Williams (Nationals) — no
- Jonathon Duniam (Liberal) — no
- Lucy Gichuhi (Liberal) — no
- Marise Payne (Liberal) — no
- Matthew Canavan (LNP) — no
- Mitch Fifield (Liberal) — no
- Nigel Scullion (Country Liberal Party) — no
- Richard Colbeck (Liberal) — no
- Scott Ryan (PRES) — no
- Simon Birmingham (Liberal) — no
- Steve Martin (Independent) — no
- Wendy Askew (Liberal) — no
- Zed Seselja (Liberal) — no
Ayes
- Anne Urquhart (Labor) — aye
- Anthony Chisholm (Labor) — aye
- Catryna Bilyk (Labor) — aye
- Chris Ketter (Labor) — aye
- Claire Moore (Labor) — aye
- David Smith (Labor) — aye
- Deborah O'Neill (Labor) — aye
- Derryn Hinch (Derryn Hinch's Justice Party) — aye
- Doug Cameron (Labor) — aye
- Gavin Marshall (Labor) — aye
- Helen Polley (Labor) — aye
- Janet Rice (Greens) — aye
- Jenny McAllister (Labor) — aye
- Jordon Steele-John (Greens) — aye
- Kim Carr (Labor) — aye
- Kimberley Kitching (Labor) — aye
- Larissa Waters (Greens) — aye
- Louise Pratt (Labor) — aye
- Malarndirri McCarthy (Labor) — aye
- Mehreen Faruqi (Greens) — aye
- Murray Watt (Labor) — aye
- Nick McKim (Greens) — aye
- Patrick Dodson (Labor) — aye
- Penny Wong (Labor) — aye
- Peter Georgiou (One Nation) — aye
- Peter Whish-Wilson (Greens) — aye
- Rachel Siewert (Greens) — aye
- Raff Ciccone (Labor) — aye
- Rex Patrick (Independent) — aye
- Richard Di Natale (Greens) — aye
- Sarah Hanson-Young (Greens) — aye
- Stirling Griff (Centre Alliance) — aye
- Sue Lines (PRES) — aye
- Tim Storer (Independent) — aye
Related bills
Only formal divisions leave a per-member record. A procedural vote is not necessarily a vote for or against a bill.