Treasury Laws Amendment (Improving Accountability and Member Outcomes in Superannuation Measures No.
Senate, 2019-02-14. affirmative: ayes 32, noes 28.
Question
The majority voted in favour of Opposition amendments ↗︎ to a Government amendment ↗︎, meaning that the Opposition amendment was successful.
Amendment text
AMENDMENTS TO GOVERNMENT AMENDMENTS [SHEET GZ227]
(1) Amendment (2), before item 1, insert: > >> 1A Subsection 10 (1) (after the definition of authorised person) >> >>> Insert: >>> >>> benchmark means a benchmark mentioned in, or specified in regulations made for the purposes of, subparagraphs 52 (9) (a) (i) and (ii) and paragraph 52 (9) (aa). >> >> 1AA Subsection 10 (1) (after the definition of Commissioner) >> >>> Insert: >>> >>> comparable choice products, in relation to a choice product, means a class of choice product specified in regulations made for the purposes of this definition that the choice product is to be compared with.
(2) Amendment (2), item 6, subparagraph 52 (9) (a) (i), omit “set under the prudential standards”, substitute “specified in regulations made for the purposes of this subparagraph”.
(3) Amendment (2), item 6, subparagraph 52 (9) (a) (ii), omit the subparagraph, substitute: > >> (ii) if the product is a choice product—a comparison of the choice product with the comparable choice products in relation to the choice product, based on factors mentioned in subsection (10A), and a comparison of the choice product with any other benchmarks specified in regulations made for the purposes of this subparagraph; and
(4) Amendment (2), item 6, after paragraph 52 (9) (a), insert: > >> *(aa) to determine, in writi ng, on an annual basis, whether each trustee of the entity is promoting the financial interests of the beneficiaries of the fund, as assessed against benchmarks specified in regulations made for the
How each member voted
How each party voted
Party labels are those recorded for this division, rather than current affiliations.
- Labor: aye 20
- Liberal: no 16
- Nationals: no 2
- Australian Conservatives: no 1
- Liberal Democratic Party: no 1
- Derryn Hinch's Justice Party: aye 1
- LNP: no 2
- Greens: aye 9
- Country Liberal Party: no 1
- Independent: no 2, aye 1
- PRES: no 1, aye 1
- DPRES: no 1
- Centre Alliance: no 1
Ayes
- Alex Gallacher (Labor) — aye
- Carol Brown (Labor) — aye
- Catryna Bilyk (Labor) — aye
- Chris Ketter (Labor) — aye
- Claire Moore (Labor) — aye
- David Smith (Labor) — aye
- Deborah O'Neill (Labor) — aye
- Derryn Hinch (Derryn Hinch's Justice Party) — aye
- Don Farrell (Labor) — aye
- Doug Cameron (Labor) — aye
- Jacinta Collins (Labor) — aye
- Janet Rice (Greens) — aye
- Jenny McAllister (Labor) — aye
- Jordon Steele-John (Greens) — aye
- Kim Carr (Labor) — aye
- Kimberley Kitching (Labor) — aye
- Kristina Keneally (Labor) — aye
- Larissa Waters (Greens) — aye
- Lisa Singh (Labor) — aye
- Louise Pratt (Labor) — aye
- Malarndirri McCarthy (Labor) — aye
- Mehreen Faruqi (Greens) — aye
- Murray Watt (Labor) — aye
- Nick McKim (Greens) — aye
- Patrick Dodson (Labor) — aye
- Penny Wong (Labor) — aye
- Peter Whish-Wilson (Greens) — aye
- Rachel Siewert (Greens) — aye
- Richard Di Natale (Greens) — aye
- Sarah Hanson-Young (Greens) — aye
- Sue Lines (PRES) — aye
- Tim Storer (Independent) — aye
Noes
- Amanda Stoker (Liberal) — no
- Anne Ruston (Liberal) — no
- Bridget McKenzie (Nationals) — no
- Concetta Fierravanti-Wells (Liberal) — no
- Cory Bernardi (Australian Conservatives) — no
- David Fawcett (Liberal) — no
- David Leyonhjelm (Liberal Democratic Party) — no
- Dean Smith (Liberal) — no
- Ian Macdonald (Liberal) — no
- James McGrath (LNP) — no
- James Paterson (Liberal) — no
- Jane Hume (Liberal) — no
- Jim Molan (Liberal) — no
- John Williams (Nationals) — no
- Jonathon Duniam (Liberal) — no
- Linda Reynolds (Liberal) — no
- Lucy Gichuhi (Liberal) — no
- Mathias Cormann (Liberal) — no
- Matthew Canavan (LNP) — no
- Mitch Fifield (Liberal) — no
- Nigel Scullion (Country Liberal Party) — no
- Rex Patrick (Independent) — no
- Richard Colbeck (Liberal) — no
- Scott Ryan (PRES) — no
- Slade Brockman (DPRES) — no
- Steve Martin (Independent) — no
- Stirling Griff (Centre Alliance) — no
- Zed Seselja (Liberal) — no
Related bills
Only formal divisions leave a per-member record. A procedural vote is not necessarily a vote for or against a bill.