Committees — Covid-19 Select Committee; Reference
Senate, 2022-03-29. negative: ayes 5, noes 34.
Question
Malcolm Roberts I move: That the following matter be referred to the Select Committee on COVID-19 for inquiry and report by 30 October 2022: The provisional approval of COVID-19 vaccines, including Pfizer, AstraZeneca, Moderna and Novavax ("the vaccines") by the Australian Technical Advisory Group on Immunisation, noting the requirement in section 22D of the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 for the Secretary of the Department of Health ("the Secretary") to ensure the quality, safety and efficacy of the vaccines were satisfactorily established for each cohort the vaccine is being approved, with particular reference to: (a) was the decision by the Secretary to not obtain patient-level data from the clinical trials of the vaccines or to independently investigate the vaccines a breach of the legislation; (b) the failure of the Australian Bureau of Statistics to ensure that statistical reporting of COVID-19 policy metrics including mortality by age/cause and live births were provided in a timely manner; (c) the process by which the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) assessed reports of vaccine harm and deaths, including failure to conduct autopsies of vaccine deaths as reported by physicians; (d) the use by the TGA of an internal version of the Database of Adverse Event Notifications, including any variance between public and internal vaccine harm data; (e) the potential for gene-based vaccine generated spike proteins to migrate into human cell nuclei to disrupt DNA repair mechanisms, and the ability of vaccine-derived RNA to be reverse transcribed into human genome; (f) failure to follow-up on animal trials of the vaccines that indicated substantial reproductive damage in lab rats, and any further work that may have been done on ensuring these vaccines have no negative effect on fertility; and (g) the suppression of alternative treatments and non-pharmaceutical health advice. Anne Ruston I seek leave to make a short statement. Slade Brockman Leave is granted for one min
How each member voted
How each party voted
Party labels are those recorded for this division, rather than current affiliations.
- Liberal: aye 2, no 15
- Labor: no 5
- Independent: no 3
- Gerard Rennick People First: aye 1
- Jacqui Lambie Network: no 1
- Greens: no 6
- One Nation: aye 2
- Nationals: no 2
- DPRES: no 1
- Centre Alliance: no 1
Ayes
- Alex Antic (Liberal) — aye
- Eric Abetz (Liberal) — aye
- Gerard Rennick (Gerard Rennick People First) — aye
- Malcolm Roberts (One Nation) — aye
- Pauline Hanson (One Nation) — aye
Noes
- Amanda Stoker (Liberal) — no
- Andrew Bragg (Liberal) — no
- Andrew McLachlan (Liberal) — no
- Anne Ruston (Liberal) — no
- Anne Urquhart (Labor) — no
- Ben Small (Liberal) — no
- Claire Chandler (Liberal) — no
- David Fawcett (Liberal) — no
- David Van (Independent) — no
- Dean Smith (Liberal) — no
- Dorinda Cox (Labor) — no
- Greg Mirabella (Liberal) — no
- Hollie Hughes (Liberal) — no
- Jacqui Lambie (Jacqui Lambie Network) — no
- Janet Rice (Greens) — no
- Jordon Steele-John (Greens) — no
- Lidia Thorpe (Independent) — no
- Louise Pratt (Labor) — no
- Matt O'Sullivan (Liberal) — no
- Mehreen Faruqi (Greens) — no
- Murray Watt (Labor) — no
- Nick McKim (Greens) — no
- Paul Scarr (Liberal) — no
- Perin Davey (Nationals) — no
- Peter Whish-Wilson (Greens) — no
- Rex Patrick (Independent) — no
- Richard Colbeck (Liberal) — no
- Sarah Hanson-Young (Greens) — no
- Sarah Henderson (Liberal) — no
- Slade Brockman (DPRES) — no
- Stirling Griff (Centre Alliance) — no
- Susan McDonald (Nationals) — no
- Tim Ayres (Labor) — no
- Wendy Askew (Liberal) — no
Related bills
Only formal divisions leave a per-member record. A procedural vote is not necessarily a vote for or against a bill.