Dissent from Ruling
House of Representatives, 2007-09-19. negative: ayes 51, noes 82.
Question
That the Speaker’s ruling be dissented from. That the Speaker’s ruling be dissented from.
How each member voted
How each party voted
Party labels are those recorded for this division, rather than current affiliations. The member list is partial: 53 recorded ayes and 84 recorded noes; the official tally above remains the source total.
- Liberal: no 69
- Labor: aye 53
- CWM: no 2
- Country Liberal Party: no 1
- Nationals: no 10
- Independent: no 2
Noes
- Alan Cadman (Liberal) — no
- Alby Schultz (Liberal) — no
- Alex Somlyay (Liberal) — no
- Alexander Downer (Liberal) — no
- Andrew Laming (Liberal) — no
- Andrew Robb (Liberal) — no
- Andrew Southcott (Liberal) — no
- Barry Haase (Liberal) — no
- Barry Wakelin (Liberal) — no
- Bob Baldwin (Liberal) — no
- Brendan Nelson (Liberal) — no
- Bronwyn Bishop (Liberal) — no
- Bruce Baird (Liberal) — no
- Bruce Billson (Liberal) — no
- Bruce Scott (CWM) — no
- Cameron Thompson (Liberal) — no
- Chris Pearce (Liberal) — no
- Christopher Pyne (Liberal) — no
- Danna Vale (Liberal) — no
- Dave Tollner (Country Liberal Party) — no
- David Fawcett (Liberal) — no
- David Jull (Liberal) — no
- De-Anne Kelly (Nationals) — no
- Dennis Jensen (Liberal) — no
- Don Randall (Liberal) — no
- Fran Bailey (Liberal) — no
- Gary Hardgrave (Liberal) — no
- Gary Nairn (Liberal) — no
- Geoff Prosser (Liberal) — no
- Greg Hunt (Liberal) — no
- Ian Causley (CWM) — no
- Ian Macfarlane (Liberal) — no
- Jackie Kelly (Liberal) — no
- Jason Wood (Liberal) — no
- Jim Lloyd (Liberal) — no
- Joe Hockey (Liberal) — no
- John Anderson (Nationals) — no
- John Cobb (Nationals) — no
- John Forrest (Nationals) — no
- John Howard (Liberal) — no
- Judi Moylan (Liberal) — no
- Julie Bishop (Liberal) — no
- Kay Elson (Liberal) — no
- Kay Hull (Nationals) — no
- Ken Ticehurst (Liberal) — no
- Kerry Bartlett (Liberal) — no
- Kevin Andrews (Liberal) — no
- Kym Richardson (Liberal) — no
- Louise Markus (Liberal) — no
- Luke Hartsuyker (Nationals) — no
- Mal Brough (Liberal) — no
- Mal Washer (Liberal) — no
- Malcolm Turnbull (Liberal) — no
- Margaret May (Liberal) — no
- Mark Baker (Liberal) — no
- Mark Vaile (Nationals) — no
- Michael Ferguson (Liberal) — no
- Michael Keenan (Liberal) — no
- Pat Farmer (Liberal) — no
- Patrick Secker (Liberal) — no
- Paul Neville (Nationals) — no
- Peter Costello (Liberal) — no
- Peter Dutton (Liberal) — no
- Peter Lindsay (Liberal) — no
- Peter McGauran (Nationals) — no
- Peter Slipper (Independent) — no
- Petro Georgiou (Liberal) — no
- Philip Ruddock (Liberal) — no
- Phillip Barresi (Liberal) — no
- Ross Vasta (Liberal) — no
- Russell Broadbent (Independent) — no
- Sharman Stone (Liberal) — no
- Sophie Mirabella (Liberal) — no
- Steven Ciobo (Liberal) — no
- Stewart McArthur (Liberal) — no
- Stuart Henry (Liberal) — no
- Sussan Ley (Liberal) — no
- Teresa Gambaro (Liberal) — no
- Tony Abbott (Liberal) — no
- Tony Smith (Liberal) — no
- Trish Draper (Liberal) — no
- Warren Entsch (Liberal) — no
- Warren Truss (Nationals) — no
- Wilson Tuckey (Liberal) — no
Ayes
- Alan Griffin (Labor) — aye
- Ann Corcoran (Labor) — aye
- Anna Burke (Labor) — aye
- Annette Ellis (Labor) — aye
- Anthony Albanese (Labor) — aye
- Anthony Byrne (Labor) — aye
- Arch Bevis (Labor) — aye
- Bob McMullan (Labor) — aye
- Bob Sercombe (Labor) — aye
- Carmen Lawrence (Labor) — aye
- Catherine King (Labor) — aye
- Chris Bowen (Labor) — aye
- Chris Hayes (Labor) — aye
- Craig Emerson (Labor) — aye
- Daryl Melham (Labor) — aye
- Dick Adams (Labor) — aye
- Duncan Kerr (Labor) — aye
- Gavan O'Connor (Labor) — aye
- Graham Edwards (Labor) — aye
- Harry Jenkins (Labor) — aye
- Jennie George (Labor) — aye
- Jenny Macklin (Labor) — aye
- Jill Hall (Labor) — aye
- Joel Fitzgibbon (Labor) — aye
- John Murphy (Labor) — aye
- Julia Gillard (Labor) — aye
- Julia Irwin (Labor) — aye
- Justine Elliot (Labor) — aye
- Kate Ellis (Labor) — aye
- Kelvin Thomson (Labor) — aye
- Kevin Rudd (Labor) — aye
- Kim Wilkie (Labor) — aye
- Kirsten Livermore (Labor) — aye
- Laurie Ferguson (Labor) — aye
- Maria Vamvakinou (Labor) — aye
- Martin Ferguson (Labor) — aye
- Michael Danby (Labor) — aye
- Michael Hatton (Labor) — aye
- Nicola Roxon (Labor) — aye
- Peter Garrett (Labor) — aye
- Robert McClelland (Labor) — aye
- Rod Sawford (Labor) — aye
- Roger Price (Labor) — aye
- Sharon Bird (Labor) — aye
- Sharon Grierson (Labor) — aye
- Simon Crean (Labor) — aye
- Stephen Smith (Labor) — aye
- Steve Georganas (Labor) — aye
- Steve Gibbons (Labor) — aye
- Tanya Plibersek (Labor) — aye
- Tony Burke (Labor) — aye
- Warren Snowdon (Labor) — aye
- Wayne Swan (Labor) — aye
Related bills
Only formal divisions leave a per-member record. A procedural vote is not necessarily a vote for or against a bill.